Skip to main content
All posts
MethodologyValuation

Don't average, explain

Unbroken · · 5 min read

A credible valuation looks at a business through more than one lens. The International Valuation Standards recognise three, and they rarely land on the same number, which is exactly the point.

Three lenses on one number

  • Income: a multiple of adjusted, maintainable EBITDA: how businesses in that sector actually trade.
  • Market: comparable transactions: what buyers have recently paid for similar businesses.
  • Asset: a build-up of the underlying assets plus a reasonable goodwill component.

Averaging hides the story

When the three don't agree, the temptation is to average them into a tidy midpoint. Resist it. An average buries the very information that makes a valuation credible: why the methods diverge in the first place.

Don't average, explain.

The EAG methodology

Triangulate instead

Pick a primary method appropriate to how that business actually trades, and run the others as cross-checks. Where one diverges by more than about 20%, treat it as a signal to investigate, not something to smooth over. Sometimes it's noise. Sometimes it's the one method catching something the others miss.

A useful discipline is to reverse-engineer a discounted cash flow from your conclusion and read off the implied discount rate. If it's absurd, your multiple is telling you something.

Conclude on a point, with reasons

Show a range, then conclude on a point, usually the midpoint, and say why. A professional gives an opinion, not a fence-sitting range. The reasoning is what survives scrutiny; the number alone never does.

Written by the Unbroken team, following a Registered Business Valuer's framework. The valuer stays responsible for the opinion.

Put the methodology to work.

See it run on a real Xero file, with your own branding in the workspace.

Keep reading